Shown with School Board members Marilyn Reis and Karlos McClure is the cost savings of Scenario 3.
It came as a shock to some school board members and most of the 130 or so teachers, parents and community members attending Monday night’s (March 15) Howard-Winneshiek School Board meeting. Most of those present were expecting to hear at least one school and half to a whole other school would be closing. So it stunned the group when school board member Duane Bodermann made a motion, seconded by Jeff Murphy to choose scenario three, which has Cresco elementary staying a traditional school and Elma, Ridgeway and Lime Springs-Chester preschool-fifth grades multi-age teaching.
Bodermann has been a proponent of multi-age teaching since discussions arose. His children have gone to the Elma Charter School which has been multi-age teaching for several years. Monday night he reiterated his daughters were taught in a multi-age classroom and are doing well in school, at least one is near the top of her class.
He also asked if the school district closes a building and loses 30 students, “What does that save us? I’d like to try to find a way to run those centers more efficiently.”
Murphy added, “Closing a building is permanent. Then if you find a savings somewhere, it’s too late.”
Karlos McClure surprised himself by saying, “I didn’t come here with this scenario in my mind. We do need a better vision.” He ended up voting for keeping all the schools open, adding to the audience, “But, don’t forget if we don’t cut at least $1 million from the budget, we’ll be here next year.” In the end all board members went with the motion.
[Scenario three will cut just over $1 million in the budget, which is workable. Originally, the board was looking to cut $1.5 million to be on the safe side.]
Some of those arguments were brought up by audience members during the first hour of the meeting as they passionately spoke about their schools and what they mean to their towns. Some commenters spoke with broken voices and shaking hands as they pled their causes. Kelly Bueller of Ridgeway asked the board to consider a five-year plan before making a decision. “The missing link here is vision. How will you arrive at a permanent decision without a vision.”
Bethany Shroyer of Lime Springs stuck up for multi-age teaching saying her kids go to Elma and it works for them. “The traditional school at Lime Springs wasn’t successful, but the charter school at Elma works. My son is excelling. He loves school.”
Erin Ludwig of Elma implored the board to keep the schools open. “Do you know the outlying centers are feeders for the junior high and high school.” She said the community of Elma wants to keep its elementary and reminded them, “We do have options [of open enrolling to other districts].”
“It should be about the kids,” implored Bob Martinek of Ridgeway.
Casey Rausch of Cresco Elementary assured those parents of outlying center students, “Cresco will embrace your kids with open arms. We’re all in this together,” adding she didn’t want to be at this same spot next year and yet . . . that is probably what will happen with the decision made by the board to keep all centers open.
In another vote, the board had a close vote for 1. making parents pay for textbooks at NICC rather than the school district paying for them, 2. dropping the activity bus after fall sports and 3. discontinuing the shuttle to Ridgeway. Voting for the proposal were Marilyn Reis, Jan Carman and McClure. Voting nay were Bodermann and Murphy.
After the vote, Ridgeway Principal Jerry Brown asked the board, “You do know cutting the shuttle is one-third of our enrollment?”
Superintendent Brian Ney explained, “This year 48 students rode the shuttle from Cresco to Ridgeway, next year would be a projected 31 students.”
Although there were some relieved parents in the audience, McClure made sure to let them know, “We didn’t make cuts deep enough.”
The issue of closing one or multiple centers is not going away. Since a decision was not made on closures this year, it will definitely be addressed next year.
Murphy said, “In my opinion, we’re just trying to get by. We’re going to have our work cut out for us.”
Filed under: Lead Articles | Leave a comment »